UA-69458566-1

Wednesday, August 26, 2020

Warning: Opposition Continues to Unify as Lukashenko Continues Crackdown

 August 26, 2020, 5:30 EDT

By George Barros

President Alexander Lukashenko effectively dispersed limited protests on August 26. There were almost no protests in Belarus on August 26, likely in part because NEXTA did not provide protest directions for August 26. A few hundred protesters arrived at the Belarusian parliament to initiate the recall of Belarusian MPs, but riot police dispersed the crowd and detained some participants.[1] Some protesters held small gatherings around Belarus, most of which consisted of fewer than 100 people.[2] Riot police dispersed these small gatherings, detaining some participants.[3]


The Lithuanian government is deepening its support for the opposition despite Kremlin warnings against “foreign interference” in Belarus. The Lithuanian Foreign Ministry proposed a list of targeted sanctions against 118 Belarusian officials, including President Lukashenko, for falsifying elections and committing violence against protesters on August 26.[4] Lithuania will ban the sanctioned individuals from entry if Lithuania’s interior Minister approves the sanctions.[5] Lukashenko and the Kremlin already accused Lithuania of “foreign interference” in Belarus and will likely reiterate those claims following these sanctions.[6]


The Belarusian Investigative Committee continues to interrogate Coordination Council members. The Investigative Committee summoned Coordination Council member and Belarusian Nobel laureate Svitlana Aleksievich for questioning on August 26.[7] Aleksievich’s questioning lasted approximately 40 minutes and ended after she refused to testify against herself.[8] Opposition figure and Coordination Councill member Maria Kolesnikova received a summons on the morning of August 26 from the Investigative Committee to appear for questioning on August 27.[9] The Investigative Committee will likely continue interrogating and intimidating opposition leaders.


More members of Svitlana Tikhanouskaya’s Coordination Council are reaching out to the Kremlin. Aleksievich made a statement following her questioning that the Coordination Council cannot succeed without international support, including that of the Kremlin.[10] Aleksievich said the Coordination Council should engage in dialogue with Russian President Vladimir Putin because currently only Lukashenko represents Belarus in talks with Russia.[11] Aleksievich said, “unfortunately, our civil society is strong, but not yet so strong, so we need help from the world, perhaps from Russia, if we can attract it together."[12] The Kremlin has not responded to Aleksievich’s comment as of this writing.


NEXTA’s rhetoric is increasingly supportive of Tikhanouskaya and Coordination Council initiatives, potentially indicating opposition consolidation behind Tikhanouskaya. NEXTA posted a statement at 12:51 am Minsk time that "Svitlana Tikhanouskaya is working more and more in the international arena every day, defending our interests. Today our President [Tikahouskaya] addressed the European Parliament with a statement that: ‘We are no longer the opposition. We are the majority. A peaceful revolution is taking place in Belarus.’"[13] NEXTA has praised Tikhanouskaya before, but its rhetoric focused more on the Coordination Council than on Tikhanouskaya directly. This statement could be an indicator that NEXTA is working to unify the opposition under Tikhanouskaya and her Coordination Council – a key first step for Belarus’ opposition to consolidate a base from which to organize and optimize its activity.


The Coordination Council launched new Telegram channel to organize recall petitions. NEXTA promoted the Coordination Council’s new "Regional Support Service" (RSS) Telegram channel in a post at 12:34 am Minsk time on August 26.[14] Both NEXTA and the Coordination Council encouraged protesters to contact the RSS via the RSS’ Telegram channel, phone number, and email in order to gain information about how to recall representatives, prepare recall appeals, and safely hold events.[15] NEXTA and the RSS Telegram channels directed protesters to the website of a Belarusian civil society organization called “Honest People.”[16] Honest People published tools on its website to help Belarusians find their officials and streamline the process of initiating recalls on August 25 or 26.[17] Kremlin-linked Belarusian opposition politician Viktar Babariko founded Honest People on June 9 in order to organize civil society activism regarding to the August 9 election.[18] Babariko served as the chairman of the Kremlin-affiliated Belgazprombank office in Belarus from 2000 to May 2020.[19] Babariko left his job at Belgazprombank in May 2020 to run against Lukashenko, but the Lukashenko-controlled Central Elections Commission blocked his candidacy on July 14.[20] Honest People’s website claims Svitlana Alexievich supports the organization, indicating Alexievich may be linked to the Kremlin via Babariko.[21]


Belarusians initiated the process to recall 20 Belarusian deputies on August 26.[22] Kolesnikova first urged Belarusians to initiate legal petitions to recall officials on August 24.[23] ISW assessed on August 24 that Lukashenko will likely not allow recall petitions to remove any officials, but the process of Belarusian opposition activists collecting signatures may facilitate the emergence of a better organized indigenous opposition network necessary for sustained and more organized protest activity.[24]


NEXTA is encouraging other activity that could lead to further local organization. NEXTA posted a statement at 3:18 am Minsk time on August 26 calling on volunteers to contribute information to another Telegram channel called "Black Book of Belarus" – a Telegram channel collecting information on Belarusian security personnel involved in violence against protesters.[25] Black Book of Belarus’ channel administrators are unknown as of this writing. NEXTA stated a "global plan" to “smash” the Lukashenko regime quickly "with minimal losses" is coming this week, suggesting NEXTA will continue to provide protesters detailed directions to coordinate activities, although NEXTA has not always followed throw on promises to provide such directions in the past.[26]


ISW will continue monitoring the situation and providing updates.

 



[1] https://twitter.com/HannaLiubakova/status/1298670145154494464;  https://twitter.com/HannaLiubakova/status/1298676180523114497 ; https://twitter.com/HannaLiubakova/status/1298695335557160967

[2] https://t(.)me/tutby_official/12273 ; https://t(.)me/nexta_live/9564 ; https://t(.)me/nexta_live/9559 ; https://t(.)me/nexta_live/9549 ; https://t(.)me/nexta_live/9542 ; https://t(.)me/nexta_live/9546?single

[3] https://twitter.com/HannaLiubakova/status/1298689573237686272

[4] https://tass(.)com/world/1193911 ; http://www.baltic-course(.)com/eng/baltic_states_cis/?doc=158626

[5] http://www.therepublic(.)com/2020/08/26/eu-lithuania-belarus-2/

[6] https://www.belta(.)by/politics/view/lavrov-vmeshatelstvo-v-belarus-izvne-proishodit-s-tseljju-navjazat-svoi-porjadki-403367-2020/ ; https://lv.sputniknews(.)ru/Latvia/20200815/14213027/My-ne-lezem-v-Belarus-Rinkevchs-nazval-bredom-slova-Lukashenko-o-inostrannom-vmeshatelstve.html

[7] https://www.rbc(.)ru/rbcfreenews/5f464dd39a7947609eb8ecd2

[8] https://gazetaby(.)com/post/dopros-aleksievich-dlilsya-40-minut-kak-tak-vyshlo/168299/

[9] https://lenta(.)ru/news/2020/08/26/kolesnikova/

[10] https://t(.)me/dimsmirnov175/14005 ; https://www.znak(.)com/2020-08-26/svetlana_aleksievich_prizvala_privlech_putina_k_obcheniyu_s_belorusskoy_oppoziciey ; https://www.forbes(.)ru/newsroom/obshchestvo/407813-nado-mozhet-byt-i-putina-privlech-aleksievich-zayavila-chto-belorusskoy-nobelevskogo-laureata-svetlany-al

[11] https://t(.)me/dimsmirnov175/14005 ; https://www.znak(.)com/2020-08-26/svetlana_aleksievich_prizvala_privlech_putina_k_obcheniyu_s_belorusskoy_oppoziciey ; https://www.forbes(.)ru/newsroom/obshchestvo/407813-nado-mozhet-byt-i-putina-privlech-aleksievich-zayavila-chto-belorusskoy-nobelevskogo-laureata-svetlany-al

[12] https://t(.)me/dimsmirnov175/14005 ; https://www.znak(.)com/2020-08-26/svetlana_aleksievich_prizvala_privlech_putina_k_obcheniyu_s_belorusskoy_oppoziciey ; https://www.forbes(.)ru/newsroom/obshchestvo/407813-nado-mozhet-byt-i-putina-privlech-aleksievich-zayavila-chto-belorusskoy-nobelevskogo-laureata-svetlany-al

[13] https://t(.)me/nexta_live/9534

[14] https://t.me/rada_vision/26 ;  https://t(

[15] https://t(.)me/rksby2020/5 ;

[16] https://t(.)me/rksby2020/5

[17] https://honest-people(.)by/ ; https://t(.)me/s/rksby2020

[18] https://vkurier(.)by/206208 ; https://babariko(.)vision/news/v-belarusi-zapustili-iniciativu-chestnye-lyudi-kak-prisoedinitsya ; https://www.instagram(.)com/p/CBEDgCBgD4A/ ; https://www.facebook.com/honestpeople.by ; http://borovljany.  Its website was registered on June 8 according to Whois information available at https://research.domaintools.com/research/whois-history/search/?q=honest..., last accessed 8/26/2020 at 3:45 p.m..

[19] https://belsat(.)eu/en/news/banker-and-philanthropist-babaryka-may-stand-in-2020-presidential-election/ ; https://www.iswresearch.org/2020/08/warning-belarussian-opposition-reach....

[20] https://www.iswresearch.org/2020/08/russia-in-review-turmoil-in-belarus....

[21] https://honest-people(.)by/

[22] https://news.tut(.)by/economics/698211.html

[23] http://www.iswresearch.org/2020/08/warning-lukashenkos-security-forces.html

[24] http://www.iswresearch.org/2020/08/warning-lukashenkos-security-forces.html

[25] https://t(.)me/nexta_tv/3840 ; https://t(.)me/s/BlackBookBelarus

[26] https://t(.)me/nexta_live/9534

Tuesday, August 25, 2020

Warning: Lukashenko Targets Opposition Leadership with Non-military Kremlin Support

 August 25, 2020, 5:30 pm EDT

By Mason Clark and George Barros

 

President Alexander Lukashenko effectively dispersed limited protests on August 25. Belarusian security forces dispersed protests across Belarus on August 25. Lukashenko resumed dispersing protests on August 24, but Belarusian security forces have not used violence against protesters since August 13. NEXTA’s call for Belarusians to gather at the Investigative Committee to support opposition leader Pavel Latushko only drew a small number of protesters. The Investigative committee released Latushko after interrogating him for 3.5 hours and forcing him to sign a non-disclosure agreement.[1] An estimated 5,000 protesters gathered without interference on Independence Square in Minsk from 6:00 pm to approximately 9:00 pm local time.[2] The Belarusian government organized a parallel pro-Lukashenko rally across the city in the Komarovsky market. Security personnel and several popular singers made speeches in favor of Lukashenko.[3] Security forces detained small numbers of protesters in Minsk the evening of August 25 after protests ended.[4] Security forces successfully deterred most protests and dispersed the remainder with little violence. Belarusian security forces likely seek to contain the scale of protests through intimidation and targeted detentions, rather than risking full-scale crackdowns.


Lukashenko is increasingly targeting opposition leaders. Belarusian authorities sentenced Minsk Tractor Works (MTZ) strike leader Sergei Dvlevsky and opposition leader Olga Kovalkova – both members of opposition leader Svetlana Tikanouskaya’s Coordination Council – to ten days in prison for organizing illegal gatherings on August 25.[5] Belarusian riot police detained Dvlevsky and Kovalkova on August 24.[6] Dvlevsky and Kovalkova will be held in the Akrestin St detention facility, a location the opposition associates with the physical abuse of detainees. The Belarusian Constitutional Court additionally ruled Tikanouskaya’s Coordination Council illegal on August 25.[7] Lukashenko likely seeks to intimidate protesters through targeted detentions with Kremlin support.  


The Kremlin is supporting Lukashenko externally despite claiming it sees no need to intervene. The Russian Orthodox Church Moscow Patriarchate (ROC) dismissed Exarch of Belarus and Metropolitan of Minsk Zaslavsky Pavel and replaced him with Bishop Benjamin of Borisov and Maryingorsk on August 25.[8] Metropolitan Pavel previously called on Lukashenko to halt violence and met with released detainees. The Kremlin often leverages the Russian Orthodox Church as a foreign policy tool and likely replaced Pavel to sideline him after his support for protesters.[9] Russian authorities detained fugitive Belarusian investigator Andrey Astapovich in Pskov, Russia, without a formal extradition request from Belarusian authorities on August 21.[10]Astapovich previously quit the Investigative Committee of Belarus and posted his desire to ”kick out the dictator [Lukashenko]” on social media.[11] Russian state-media outlet RT is additionally overtly supporting Lukashenko’s crackdown on protesters, running English-language stories on August 25 claiming Western media does not cover the point of view of the security forces.[12] The Kremlin will likely increasingly support Lukashenko externally – through media support and detention of opposition supporters - despite claiming it is not involved in Belarus. 

Lukashenko mobilized the Belarusian military reserve for the first time. The Belarusian Ministry of Defense announced on August 24 it brought all military units to the highest level of combat readiness, including calling up unspecific units of reservists.[13] This is the first time Lukashenko has attempted to mobilize the reserve since protests began. Belarus’ reserve had approximately 289,500 personnel as of 2019.[14] Several Belarusian veterans have supported the opposition protests by recording themselves throwing away their uniforms.[15] Lukashenko likely retains the support of the majority of the security forces, but risks exposing fissures by calling up reservists who may oppose him. 

 

Opposition leader Svetlana Tikanouskaya is likely losing influence over the protest movement despite outreach to the EU. Tikanouskaya spoke to an emergency session of the European Parliament via video call on August 25, during which she thanked EU states that did not recognize Belarus’ elections.[16] Tikanouskaya reiterated she seeks to use the Coordination Council to negotiate with Lukashenko to hold new elections.[17] Lukashenko is unlikely to engage with Tikanouskaya despite her outreach. Tikanouskaya risks losing influence over the situation on the ground as her representatives in Belarus are detained.


The Kremlin continues to maintain flexibility toward the opposition and seeks to prevent Western engagement in Belarus. Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov met with US Deputy Secretary of State Stephen Biegun in Moscow to discuss Belarus on August 25.[18] The Kremlin claimed Biegun said the US does not want to create an “artificial crisis” in Belarus.[19] The Kremlin claimed both parties agreed they are interested in establishing a dialogue between Lukashenko and the opposition.[20] The US State Department has not yet released a readout of the meeting. Lavrov accused Poland and Lithuania of attempting to provoke violence in Belarus due to their “dissatisfaction” in how the situation in Belarus is “normalizing.”[21] The Kremlin will likely continue to portray Poland and Lithuania as engaging in ”foreign interference” in Belarus to frame the protests as illegitimate and justify a possible intervention. The Kremlin is likely maintaining the possibility of outreach to the opposition as a stalling tactic but sees no direct interest in supporting Tikanouskaya over Lukashenko.

ISW will continue monitoring the situation and providing updates.

Click here to download the PDF.


[1] https://reform((.))by/158797-latushko-dejatelnost-koordinacionnogo-soveta-budet-prodolzhena.

[3] https://news.tut((.))by/economics/697957.html.

[5] https://news.tut((.))by/society/698067.html.

[7] https://eng.belta((.))by/society/view/belarus-constitutional-court-chief-coordination-council-is-unconstitutional-132865-2020/.

[8] https://amp-charter97-org(.)cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/amp.charter97.org/ru/news/2020/8/25/390868/.

[10] https://belsat(.)eu/en/news/fugitive-belarusian-investigator-detained-in-russia-without-extradition-request; https://www.mk-pskov(.)ru/social/2020/08/25/pskovskiy-advokat-bezhavshego-iz-belorussii-sledovatelya-zagruzili-v-mashinu-i-uvezli.html.

[11] https://belsat(.)eu/en/news/fugitive-belarusian-investigator-detained-in-russia-without-extradition-request/.

[13] https://www.mil(.)by/ru/news/104705/.

[18] https://www.mid(.)ru/ru/foreign_policy/news/-/asset_publisher/cKNonkJE02Bw/content/id/4299276.

[19] https://www.mid(.)ru/ru/foreign_policy/news/-/asset_publisher/cKNonkJE02Bw/content/id/4299276.

[20] https://www.mid(.)ru/ru/foreign_policy/news/-/asset_publisher/cKNonkJE02Bw/content/id/4299276.

[21] https://www.mid(.)ru/ru/foreign_policy/news/-/asset_publisher/cKNonkJE02Bw/content/id/4299276.

Monday, August 24, 2020

Warning: Lukashenko’s Security Forces Detain Belarusian Opposition Leaders

 August 24, 2020, 6:30 pm EDT

By George Barros

The Lukashenko regime began a new phase in its crackdown by starting to disperse and arrest protesters and conduct targeted arrests against opposition leaders in Minsk for the first time since August 19. Belarusian authorities detained Minsk Tractor Works (MTZ) strike leader Sergei Dvlevsky and opposition leader Olga Kovalkova – both members of opposition leader Svitlana Tikanouskaya’s Coordination Council – on August 24.[1] Belarusian security forces also detained Alexander Lavrinovich – the strike leader at the state-owned Minsk Wheel Tractor Plant (MZKT) – and Anatoly Bokun – the strike leader at the Belaruskali potash fertilizer plant – on August 24.[2] Authorities released Bokun after fining him 675 rubles on August 24.[3] Authorities had previously arrested a key Belaruskali strike organizer on August 20, but he reportedly managed to escape his detention facility.[4] Lavrinovich’s status is unknown as of this update.[5] Authorities brought Kovalkova to the Akrestin St. detention facility – a location the opposition associates with the physical abuse of detainees.[6] The opposition had marched on the Akrestin St. detention facility in a poorly organized effort directed by the NEXTA Telegram channel on August 18.[7] The Belarusian Ministry of Internal Affairs (MVD) has not attempted to disperse any protests in Minsk or detain protesters since August 19.[8] Belarusian authorities ended the last round of mass detentions on August 14 when they released a large number of detainees. The renewed dispersions and arrests are likely intended to intimidate protesters. The Lukashenko regime will likely increase the scope of targeted arrests against opposition leaders and use force against protesters in the coming week.

President Alexander Lukashenko likely took advantage of the small scale of protests today to demonstrate his renewed willingness to use force to disperse them and to arrest demonstrators. There were no large-scale protests in Belarus on August 24. A few hundred protesters came to Independence Square in Minsk around 7:00 pm Minsk time but riot police detained some and dispersed the rest.[9] Localized small-scale protests continue to occur in Belarus but security forces are consistently dispersing them.[10]


NEXTA issued directions for new protest activity for August 25 that will likely lead to direct confrontation between protesters and Belarusian authorities given Lukashenko’s actions. A NEXTA post at 10:29 pm Minsk time on August 24 directed Belarusians to gather at the Belarusian Investigative Committee in Minsk at 10:00 am local time and then gather at Independence Square at 6:00 pm.[11] The Investigative Committee of Belarus summoned Pavel Latushko, a Coordinating Council member, to appear at its premises for questioning about alleged “calls for actions aimed at causing harm to national security” on August 25 at 10:00 Minsk time.[12] NEXTA is likely trying to direct protesters to the Investigative Committee building to disrupt Latushko’s scheduled questioning. NEXTA also instructed residents in other cities to hold their own demonstrations at 6:00 pm Minsk time on August 25. NEXTA  stated that a ”detailed strategy” on how to ”return power to the people” and an ”important appeal from Svitlana Tikanouskaya” would be presented sometime this week.[13] Belarusian security forces will likely confront protesters at the Investigative Committee building.  It is unclear if they will attempt to disrupt or otherwise interfere with protests at Independence Square, which they have not done over the past 10 days.


The opposition may be setting conditions for a grassroots leadership structure to emerge inside Belarus. Opposition leader Olga Kolesnikova urged Belarusians to initiate legal petitions to recall their MPs and regional officials in a Coordination Council briefing on August 24. Lukashenko will likely not allow this effort to remove any officials. The process of Belarusian opposition activists collecting signatures, however, may facilitate the emergence of a better organized indigenous opposition network necessary for sustained and more organized protest activity. The Belarusian opposition movement currently lacks a clear leadership structure inside Belarus and is dependent on announcements from Tikanouskaya in Lithuania or NEXTA in Poland to organize large-scale protests.[14] This initiative may also be an effort by the Vilnius-based Tikanouskaya to develop her own abilities to control protest events in Belarus and thereby reduce her reliance on the Warsaw-based NEXTA, which has repeatedly appeared to disrupt her plans.[15]


The US is engaging the Belarusian opposition in a high-profile manner despite Kremlin warnings not to meet with opposition figures. US Deputy Secretary of State Stephen Biegun met with Tikanouskaya in Vilnius, Lithuania on August 24.[16] Biegun urged Lukashenko at a press conference on the same day to facilitate dialogue and engage all stakeholders.[17] Biegun also stated the US has no “indication beyond some of the public remarks that we’ve heard” that the Kremlin is preparing a possible military intervention into Belarus.[18] Biegun’s statement contradicts elements of ISW’s previous assessments. The Kremlin and Lukashenko previously accused the US of “foreign interference” in Belarus.[19] "Foreign interference" is a legal ground for a military assistance according to Russia and Belarus’ Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) agreements. The Kremlin previously stated it observed “foreign interference” in Belarus but has not military intervened because Lukashenko has not asked for assistance.[20] The Kremlin has stated repeatedly it would intervene military in Belarus at Lukashenko’s first request.[21]  


The Kremlin is likely extracting concessions from Lukashenko in return for supporting his continued rule.  Concessions likely include the deployment of Russian military hardware in Belarus. Russian President Vladimir Putin and Lukashenko had their fourth phone call since protests began on August 24.[22] Lukashenko informed Putin about his measures to restore order in Belarus. The Belarusian Defense Ministry reportedly signed a deal with the Kremlin-owned Almaz-Antey defense company on August 24 at the Army 2020 annual international military-technical forum in Moscow. The Belarusian defense minister reportedly signed a contract for cooperation on air defense systems until 2025.[23] Almaz-Antey is the holding company for the manufacturers of the S-300, S-400, and S-500 Russian air-defense systems.[24] Lukashenko may have agreed to this deal as a condition for Kremlin support in Belarus.


The Kremlin likely seeks to deploy anti-access/area denial weapon systems in Belarus to contest NATO and Eastern European airspace more than it already does with systems deployed in Kaliningrad. Lukashenko previously declined the Kremlin’s multiple requests to expand strategic Russian airbases in Belarus since at least 2015.[25] ISW assessed on August 21 that Lukashenko likely made concessions to Putin under duress while Lukashenko was losing control over Belarus before the Kremlin’s intervention.[26]


ISW is monitoring the situation and will provide further updates.

Click here to download the PDF. 



[1] https://www.intellinews(.)com/leading-members-of-belarus-coordinating-council-and-strike-movements-have-been-arrested-as-belarus-lukashenko-starts-crackdown-190296/

[3] https://news.tut(.)by/economics/697923.html

[4] https://www.rbc(.)ru/politics/21/08/2020/5f3fcf9a9a794700f5463764

[5] https://news.tut(.)by/economics/697923.html

[6] https://www.facebook.com/KavalkovaVolya/posts/1669394853218051 ; https://www.dw(.)com/ru/%D0%BE%D0%BA%D1%80%D0%B5%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B8%D0%BD%D0%B0-%D0%BA%D0%B0%D0%BA-%D1%81%D0%B8%D0%BC%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%BB-%D0%B6%D0%B5%D1%81%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BA%D0%BE%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B8-%D1%81%D0%B8%D0%BB%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2-%D0%B2-%D0%B1%D0%B5%D0%BB%D0%B0%D1%80%D1%83%D1%81%D0%B8-18082020/av-54614818 ;

[8] https://meduza(.)io/news/2020/08/19/omon-razognal-miting-u-minskogo-traktornogo-zavoda-do-etogo-sluchaya-aktsiyam-protesta-v-gorode-ne-prepyatstvovali-nedelyu

[10] https://t(.)me/nexta_live/9435

[11] https://t(.)me/nexta_live/9454

[12] https://naviny(.)by/new/20200824/1598274073-latushko-vyzvali-v-sledstvennyy-komitet-na-25-avgusta

[13] https://t(.)me/nexta_live/9454

 

[20] https://www.belta(.)by/politics/view/lavrov-vmeshatelstvo-v-belarus-izvne-proishodit-s-tseljju-navjazat-svoi-porjadki-403367-2020

[22] http://kremlin(.)ru/events/president/news/63938

[23] https://www.rbc(.)ru/politics/24/08/2020/5f43c9f29a7947ddefc83127

[25] https://www.rbc(.)ru/politics/06/10/2015/5613ebe59a794769839c9e3f ; https://www.vesti(.)ru/article/1501418; https://www.gazeta(.)ru/army/2019/11/14/12811502.shtml